This weekend my wife and I headed out to catch the latest Liam Neeson movie,
A Walk Among The Tombstones. Suck it,
The Maze Runner. You're not getting a goddamn dollar out of me.
First, a quickie, spoiler free review: I enjoyed it. I like it more the further removed I am from watching it (a good sign,) though it definitely isn't perfect.
Tombstones is sort of a semi-modern update to the old school style detective story. You have your damaged goods main character, working for an employer of dubious employ (in the 40's and 50's they were mobsters; the updated analog makes them all drug dealers.) You have your somewhat twisty investigation that reveals more than anyone initially let on. You have your noir-ish moments where you don't know who or what to trust. And I guess because test audiences couldn't handle 113 minutes of Neeson being gruff as hell, you have a young sidekick.
All of it is pretty standard stuff for the genre, but two things help raise it up from "mediocre" to "pretty good":
1) Neeson is great at playing damaged goods tough guys, and he does a tremendous amount of work elevating the character of Matthew Scudder beyond just another gumshoe. There are few actors who would have been able to handle the material as well, and a miscast here would have sunk the movie. Which would have been a damn shame because...
2) There aren't many movies like this around nowadays. You get a lot of serial killer movies, crime dramas, tough guy redemption stories, character vehicles, etc, but very few people are making detective story/noir thriller movies anymore. It's understandable, given the market - studios are banking on big, flashy movies to draw audiences in, two things which
Tombstones definitely is not - but it's a damn shame for anyone who is a fan of that style of movie.
Because of that, I'm willing to cut
Tombstones slack I may not have otherwise. Though even with that consideration, I think
Tombstones still holds up fairly well.
I can readily recommend
Tombstones to anyone who is looking for a detective/noir-style movie, with a double down bonus if you like Liam Neeson. This movie is fairly far removed from his recent action movie star stint, so don't expect him to come in guns blazing and faces punched. There are some fisticuffs and guns are indeed blazed in a few parts but
Taken 3 this is not (and thank all of the gods for that.)
After the break I'll dive into some move elements of the movie that struck me. This is getting into
spoiler territory, so anyone who hasn't watched the movie should beware. I'm not sure how far I'll get into deep spoilers but I'm probably going to reveal some things you're better off experiencing for the first time during the movie.